I’ve been a bit po-faced about it, I think, and to be honest, probably a bit of an armchair revolutionary. All talk and no do.
That’s not to say I’ve changed my mind. I haven’t. But while I’ve been suggesting all sorts of radical action to tackle the myriad of problems people here face, it was a news story I saw this week which got me thinking about what could perhaps be an even more radical plan. And one that could have almost immediate results too.
The news story I’m talking about is one in which the British think tank The Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR) suggests that scrapping all public holidays would boost the UK economy by an extra £19 billion a year.
While they don’t explicitly suggest that they should all be scrapped, they do suggest that they should be “spread out” a bit more so that businesses aren’t hit all in one go. I guess having too many holidays all together is terrible for business as it means the poor people get to have a day off and the fat cats can’t earn another million as quickly as they’d like to.
Of course, their suggestions are idiotic. As a GMB union spokesman so aptly put it “We could send kids down the mines again too and go back to working six days a week again.”
So where does Spain fit into all this?
Well, let’s put this in perspective. In an average year, the UK has eight public holidays - two at Christmas, one at New Year (or two if you’re in Scotland), two at Easter, two in May and one in August. This year, because of the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee, everyone gets an extra one in June too.
Wow. Nine public holidays this year. That’s a lot.
Except if you live in Spain. If you live in Spain, right now you’re saying: “Nine? Is that it?” Only nine??!”
For in Spain, there are a minimum – yes, a minimum - of 13 public holidays. Let’s count the ones in the Seville area alone (as different parts of the country have different extra days).
There’s January 1, then there’s January 6, then we wait a little bit - but not much - for January 23 when there’s a local holiday. Then we have to wait a whole four weeks for another holiday on February 28. After that, we’ve got two days at Easter, which this year was April 5 and 6.
However, Easter Week in Seville is when all the processions take place and a lot of people take extra time off work then as well. Next there’s the big Feria week in Seville at the end of April – more about that next week – with most people in the city taking several days off. After that, we have to wait a massive four days until the May 1 holiday.
I haven’t finished yet.
While the next official holiday is August 15, during July and August many businesses cut down their hours or close up as the long, hot summer kicks in. After that, we have to wait until October for the next holiday, which comes on the 12th. Then there’s another one on November 1, then when you get close to Christmas, you have one on December 6 and another on December 8.
This, in itself, is daft, because, as happened this year, those days fell on a Tuesday and a Thursday, which meant that lots of people actually took the Wednesday off as well. Why not? I would.
Then, of course, we come to Christmas, when perhaps surprisingly, only December 25 is a holiday, not December 26.
So what’s my point? Am I suggesting that those CEBR morons are right? That maybe there are too many holidays and the poor workers have far too much time to themselves.
No, it’s far simpler than that.
When there’s a holiday in the UK, most High Street shops are open (except on Christmas Day). It makes sense, doesn’t it. If you’re on holiday, you want to go out and spend your money on stuff. Even on Sundays, the vast majority of shops are open too. Sundays are pretty much as busy as Saturdays. And with the tills ringing, the shops do well and the economy picks up.
Except, that is, if you’re in Spain.
With the exception of Madrid and a few other places, when there’s a public holiday all the shops are shut. What’s the point of that?? You’ve got all these people on holiday with cash to spend and nowhere to spend it.
Even on Sundays virtually no shops are open in Seville. Now, I know what you’re thinking. Seville is a strongly Catholic city and Sunday is a special day.
No it’s not. While the majority of people might call themselves Catholic, the figures show that only a minority of people actually go to Church every week. The rest are all down the bars getting pissed and eating tapas, as they’re the only places that are open on a Sunday.
So, that’s it. Open the shops on public holidays and on Sundays, let the people in to spend their cash, the shops take more money, shop workers have the – voluntary – chance to earn extra wages, the businesses see their turnover go up and everyone’s happy.
Look, I know what I’m saying is all a bit new for some people. I get it. It’s a bit of a culture thing here. People have never really done it. It might be more difficult for smaller shops to do it. It would all be a bit strange and unnerving and you’d have old people saying things like: “It wasn’t like that in my day. Youngsters today, it’s all wrong, the country’s going to the dogs blah blah blah.” No doubt, some of the more religious lot would get their knickers in a twist over it too. They’d probably claim that shops opening on a Sunday or a public holiday would mark the onset of godlessness, devil worship and Satanic sacrifices across the country or something like that.
The irony is that the only time when shops do open on a Sunday in Seville is in the lead-up to Christmas! The very time when we’re supposed to be celebrating the birth of the bloke who said in the first place that Sunday was a day of rest.
Opening on a Sunday and a public holiday will not precipitate dark times. As we all know, that hasn’t happened in the UK. They’ve had Sunday trading for nearly 20 years and they’re not godless heathens worshipping at the foot of false idols (unless they’re credit cards of course). They’re doing ok, apart from the odd Summer riot here and there.
So, what about it? I know that in several parts of Spain the restrictions on Sunday shopping have been loosened in recent years. It’s just that a lot of people don’t take the opportunity offered.
If the boycott of the banks and the rolling general strikes don’t work, at least in the short term, then maybe this will.
It’s just an idea.
Now you see the difference between the Uk ( and also another European Countries) and Spain? And I can tell you is nothing to do with Catholic or any other religion, is about working culture, people here are not educated to work, they want to earn a lot of money by working not too much. If you don't beleive me, have a look to a study of young people in Spain and particularly in Andalusia, more than the 60% want to be civil servant!!!
ReplyDeleteIt used to be that in the UK you could have a "job for life" in the civil service. Not any more. And I guess it's the same for Spain too now.
DeleteMaybe you are right, but I can't see how this could help now, I mean in this critical moment. Although from the next Sunday all the shops were open, I don't think the mayority of the people will go shopping, unless they have an emergency or have something in particular to buy that day, as my relatives who live in Madrid told me. Moreover, we prefer to spend our free time with family or friends rather than waste it in a shopping centre. And if it's in a bar or a restaurant, it's much better, don't forget they are part of the pillars of our most important industry: the tourism. I think that the solution to the crisis is not as simple as it seems and it depends on a lot of actions that needs to be taken. What actions? Regrettably, I don't know.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you this week. I has been a lot of times in UK and I am used to going shopping whenever you need, Monday or Sunday. Openning on Sundays would make that owners need more workers, so this measure would help to our current big problem: unemployment. More people working means more people with money to spend,so more money for ownwers and more opening shops. And the circle starts: more owners hiring. That is Economy. Instead of it,we are in a negative circle now.
ReplyDeleteI think that people shouldn’t judge by appearances or stereotypes. The English are not all serious and boring nor do they only eat fish and chips. Not all Americans are fat and superficial . Not all the Germans are very organized and disciplined people. And of course, not all the Spanish are lazy. But, Would it be better to work all time?. Perhaps we should become like the Japanese. What is best?.
ReplyDeleteMany stereotypes about Spain have little to do with today’s reality.
I didn't say the Spanish were lazy. I just said that they should think about opening on a Sunday as it might help to generate a bit of extra income. But I agree with you that Americans are fat and superficial.
DeleteIt could be an opcion, but people need to rest. And, as you have written, it looks like Spanish people have more holidays than the rest but that isn't true. Besides, how are people going to spend more money if they don't have it?
ReplyDeleteYou said a solution for the employers that sounds too easy, and it isn´t. People with their owns business have to rest some days of the week as everybody do.
ReplyDeleteAbout holidays in Spain we don´t have too much holidays than other countris, it´s true that maybe we have more than the common, but I think that reducing the holidays won´t safe the economy in Spain.
I think the problem of opening or not shops on Sunday has nothing to do with religion, but with laws. As long as I'm concerned, opening on Sunday is forbidden, except for Madrid. Maybe a reform in the laws would be a solution to increase the economical activity of Spain, but maybe before we should know if spaniards would want to go shopping the public day of rest.
ReplyDeleteNo it's not you see! People think it is, ut you can open on a Sunday if you want to.
DeleteI think that open some shops on Sundays it isn't profitable because the mayority of people spend their time traveling or being with their family or friends. Maybe supermarkets should open in the morning to people who have to buy food for this day or people who work during whole week and Sundays is the only day that they can buy all things.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you, but at the same time I don´t think that something as simple as opening stores on Sundays and holidays may end up with something as big as the crisis that we are. Although this idea seems very good, because people should stop complaining and start doing something and the economy would be reactivated. I also think that many people will go shopping on Sundays if they can ´t do it during the week because of work.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you in every points. Nowadays we´re in "crisis" and I think that people ought to work more than they do, because you can listen somebody talk about the crisis and their disappointment on the cut-down that the government has done. But as soon as they are saying it, you can see sundays all bars full, or the just on a monday, or wednesday. So people should to save up for bad times in the future and small business need to work more in case they want to be on the top.
ReplyDeleteYour plan is simple but effective, but maybe you'll have to include a little DNA manipulation and mix some Chinese cells in our Spanish genetic chain. In my opinion, It woud be great to have shops opened on Sundays and the owners should have the possibility to choose if they want to work on holidays.
ReplyDeleteBut, I'm not sure if "crisis" would end so easy. Now, with a 27% of people unemployed, you see the same people buying stuff for the "Feria" like there's no tomorrow.